Over the past few years, Bitcoin has evolved from a niche digital currency to a trillion-dollar asset class at its peak. Along the way, many investors and enthusiasts have hailed it as a potential “digital gold,” capable of hedging against inflation and providing portfolio diversification. However, if you’ve watched the markets closely, you might have noticed that when traditional equities or other “risk assets” sell off, Bitcoin often drops in tandem. Despite claims that Bitcoin should be a safe haven, its price can still behave like a high-risk tech stock. So, why does Bitcoin still seem to be correlated to other risk assets—especially during sell-offs? Let’s break it down.
1. Shared Market Psychology
One of the most straightforward explanations for Bitcoin’s correlation with equities is that human psychology and emotion drive market movements. When panic sets in—perhaps because of looming recession fears or surprising geopolitical events—investors tend to offload assets that they perceive as high-risk. Bitcoin, with its historical volatility and limited track record compared to blue-chip stocks or government bonds, often lands in the crosshairs of this risk-off sentiment.
Even though Bitcoin has unique properties (such as a finite supply and a censorship-resistant payment system), in times of crisis, the nuance of these advantages often gets lost. Investors may decide to reduce any positions they view as volatile, and this group frequently includes cryptocurrency.
2. Institutional Players and Portfolio Rebalancing
A growing share of Bitcoin’s trading volume now comes from institutional investors—such as hedge funds, family offices, and large asset managers. Many of these institutions categorize Bitcoin alongside other high-growth or speculative technology investments. When market conditions sour (for instance, due to rising interest rates or a broader economic slowdown), these investors tend to rebalance their portfolios by trimming positions that fall into the “risk” bucket.
In other words, when tech stocks sink and institutional investors shift capital away from high-risk plays, Bitcoin typically gets swept up in the same selling pressure as stocks like Tesla or Apple. This institutional approach to portfolio management inadvertently ties Bitcoin’s fate to the broader equity market.
3. Margin Calls and Liquidity Needs
During a sudden stock market downturn, some investors—especially those using leverage—face margin calls. A margin call occurs when an account’s equity falls below the required maintenance margin, forcing the investor to add more cash or liquidate positions to bring the account back into compliance.
If these investors hold a variety of assets, they will look for the most liquid positions to sell quickly—often large-cap stocks and cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin. Because Bitcoin trades 24/7 and typically has robust liquidity (compared to smaller altcoins or less liquid assets), it can be one of the first assets sold to raise the cash needed to meet margin calls. This forced selling drives down BTC’s price at the same time as the stock market is dropping.
4. The “Buy the Dip” Phenomenon
Another reason Bitcoin may sell off with equities is what some call the “buy the dip” rotation strategy. When the stock market experiences a significant decline, some investors may liquidate their crypto holdings to buy stocks at discounted prices—especially when they believe these stocks have strong fundamentals that will lead to a rebound. In this scenario, Bitcoin is viewed more as a tradable asset to generate liquidity than as a long-term store of value.
On the flip side, in bull markets, investors sometimes do the opposite: they use profits from stocks or bonds to purchase Bitcoin, chasing its high-upside potential. These inflows help push Bitcoin’s price higher. But when conditions reverse, the outflows can be just as dramatic.
5. Shifting Correlations
It’s important to note that correlations aren’t fixed. Over shorter time frames, Bitcoin’s correlation with the S&P 500 or Nasdaq can spike when market sentiment becomes uniformly risk-averse. At other times—particularly in crypto-specific bullish cycles—Bitcoin can decouple from equities and follow its own trajectory, driven by crypto-centric narratives like halving cycles or major protocol upgrades (e.g., Ethereum’s network changes).
Historically, there have been periods where Bitcoin showed very little correlation to traditional assets. However, the increasing participation of mainstream investors has made such decoupling events less common in recent years, at least during moments of high market stress.
6. The Debate Over “Real Value”
Underpinning the entire discussion is an ongoing debate about Bitcoin’s intrinsic value. Critics argue that Bitcoin lacks fundamentals such as earnings, dividends, or direct industrial use. Proponents assert that Bitcoin’s value lies in its secure, decentralized network, scarcity (capped at 21 million coins), and potential as a hedge against inflation or currency debasement.
Regardless of where you stand on the “real value” debate, the perception of Bitcoin’s risk profile often supersedes theoretical fundamentals. In other words, the market’s perception—rather than a definitive consensus on Bitcoin’s intrinsic value—shapes price movement. And in periods of high stress, that perception tends toward viewing Bitcoin as a speculative, volatile asset.
7. Macro Drivers: Interest Rates and Liquidity
When central banks raise interest rates, it typically cools off investor appetite for growth stocks and other riskier assets by making safe bonds relatively more attractive. Likewise, quantitative tightening reduces liquidity in the financial system. These macro forces can cause capital to flow out of stocks—and by extension, out of cryptocurrencies as well.
In this way, Bitcoin’s price is indirectly tied to the global macro environment, much like equities and other risk-on investments. As long as Bitcoin remains part of the “risk-on” conversation, it will likely react similarly to broader market swings influenced by interest rates and monetary policy.
Final Thoughts
While Bitcoin advocates continue to champion the cryptocurrency as a unique, uncorrelated asset, market reality often tells a different story—especially during significant sell-offs. Bitcoin’s volatility, institutional investor behavior, and overall risk-off sentiment in traditional markets frequently synchronize its price movements with those of equities.
That said, correlations can change, and Bitcoin’s price history has shown that the cryptocurrency can decouple from equities under certain conditions—especially when crypto-specific catalysts dominate the news cycle or when retail-driven enthusiasm overtakes traditional finance sentiment. Over the longer term, as Bitcoin matures and its use cases become clearer (or as the global monetary landscape shifts), it’s possible that these correlations may weaken.
For now, though, it’s prudent to assume that Bitcoin is not a magical exception to broader market trends. In high-risk, volatile environments, it often moves in lockstep with equities and other speculative assets. Understanding why this happens can help investors anticipate price movements, manage portfolio risk, and maintain a level-headed approach to this exciting but unpredictable market.
Explore More:
Leave a Reply