Gold has been synonymous with wealth and stability for thousands of years. Its role as a store of value, a hedge against inflation, and a symbol of prosperity has cemented its position in global economies. But what if gold lost its monetary value entirely? What if people stopped assigning value to it as an investment, a currency, or a store of wealth? What would remain is its intrinsic value derived from industrial and practical uses.
In this post, we’ll explore how gold’s price might change if it were stripped of its monetary status, examining the implications for its industrial uses, jewelry demand, and the impact on global markets and central banks.
The Current Value of Gold: Driven by Money and Tradition
Today, gold’s price is determined by a combination of factors:
- Investment Demand: Gold serves as a hedge against inflation and a store of value. It accounts for a significant portion of global gold demand.
- Jewelry: Nearly half of the world’s gold is used for jewelry, driven by cultural traditions and its association with wealth.
- Central Bank Reserves: Central banks hold approximately 35,000 metric tons of gold (worth over $2 trillion) as a monetary asset to diversify their reserves.
- Industrial Uses: About 7% of annual gold demand (~330 metric tons) is driven by industrial applications, such as electronics, medical devices, and aerospace.
The value of gold is overwhelmingly tied to its monetary role and cultural associations. But if we strip those away, gold’s price would plummet to reflect only its practical utility.
What Would Happen If Gold Lost Its Monetary Value?
1. Jewelry Demand Would Decline
Gold’s dominance in the jewelry industry stems largely from its symbolic value as a precious metal. In cultures where gold is seen as a status symbol (e.g., India and China), the demand for gold jewelry is immense. However:
- Loss of Prestige: If gold no longer carried monetary significance, its symbolic and cultural appeal would diminish, reducing demand for gold jewelry.
- Price-Driven Demand Increase? A sharp drop in gold prices could make it accessible to a broader audience, driving some demand for affordable gold jewelry. However, alternatives like silver, platinum, or synthetic materials could fill this void.
Net Effect: Jewelry demand would likely shrink significantly, though not disappear entirely.
2. Central Banks Would Liquidate Their Holdings
Central banks collectively hold over 35,000 metric tons of gold. This vast reserve is a relic of gold’s historical role as a monetary standard and its use in currency backing. If gold no longer held monetary value:
- Massive Sell-Offs: Central banks would have no incentive to hold gold, leading to widespread liquidation. This would flood the market with supply, further depressing prices.
- Market Disruption: Such a sell-off could destabilize the gold market in the short term, overwhelming industrial demand and collapsing prices.
3. Industrial Demand Would Become Gold’s Primary Driver
Without monetary or symbolic value, gold’s price would depend entirely on its industrial applications. Gold is valued in industry for its:
- Electronics: As a superior conductor, gold is used in connectors, switches, and circuit boards.
- Medical Uses: Gold is used in dentistry, medical devices, and treatments for conditions like arthritis.
- Aerospace: Gold’s radiation-reflecting properties make it vital in spacecraft.
- Catalysis: Emerging uses in chemical reactions further highlight gold’s utility.
However, gold’s industrial demand is modest compared to its monetary and jewelry demand. In 2023, only 330 metric tons of gold (7% of total demand) were used industrially. If industrial demand were the sole driver of gold’s value, its price would fall dramatically.
How Much Might Gold Be Worth Without Monetary Value?
To estimate gold’s price without monetary or jewelry demand:
- Proportion of Industrial Use: Industrial demand accounts for only 7% of current gold use. If we adjust the current price of $1,900 per ounce to reflect this share, gold might be worth $133 per ounce.
- Substitutes and Reduced Demand: Many of gold’s industrial applications (e.g., electronics) can use substitutes like silver or copper. If gold’s price dropped, industrial demand might shrink further, stabilizing its price around $50–$100 per ounce.
- Production Costs: The average cost to mine and refine an ounce of gold is $1,200–$1,400. If prices fell below this level, mining would become unprofitable, reducing supply. This could create a floor for gold prices around $100–$150 per ounce.
Final Estimate: Without monetary value, one ounce of gold might be worth $50–$150, depending on industrial demand, substitutes, and production costs.
Economic and Geopolitical Implications
1. Strengthened Role of the U.S. Dollar
Gold competes with the U.S. dollar as a store of value and hedge against inflation. If gold lost its monetary value:
- The dollar’s dominance as a reserve currency would increase.
- Investors would shift to dollar-denominated assets like Treasury bonds, strengthening the U.S. economy.
2. Reallocation of Capital
Gold investments currently represent a $12 trillion market. If gold lost its monetary appeal, this capital could flow into other assets:
- Infrastructure projects
- Technology innovation
- Green energy investments
This could boost economic growth in sectors beyond mining.
3. Impact on the Mining Industry
Gold mining is a $200 billion global industry. A collapse in gold prices would devastate mining companies, especially in regions reliant on gold exports (e.g., South Africa, Peru). Miners might pivot to other metals, such as lithium or copper, which are critical for renewable energy.
Would Gold Still Have a Place in Society?
Even without monetary value, gold would retain some value due to its:
- Industrial Properties: Its unique physical and chemical properties ensure continued demand in technology, medicine, and aerospace.
- Cultural Significance: In some cultures, gold’s symbolic value might persist, albeit at lower prices.
However, gold would no longer serve as the universal symbol of wealth and stability it is today.
Conclusion
If gold lost its monetary value, its price would plummet, likely stabilizing between $50–$150 per ounce, reflecting only its industrial and practical utility. Jewelry demand would shrink, central banks would liquidate reserves, and the global gold market would be overwhelmed with excess supply.
While this shift could reinforce the dominance of the U.S. dollar and redirect investment capital to other sectors, it would also upend industries, economies, and traditions reliant on gold’s monetary status.
This thought experiment underscores the profound influence of gold’s symbolic and monetary role in our global economy. Without it, gold might still shine, but not nearly as brightly.
Sources:
What do you think? Would gold still have a place in the world without its monetary value? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Related Reading: