For centuries, gold has been revered as the ultimate store of value—a tangible asset immune to the whims of central banks and the volatility of fiat currencies. However, in the modern financial landscape, gold’s price is not solely determined by straightforward supply and demand dynamics. A plethora of financial instruments have been engineered, intentionally or otherwise, to influence and often suppress gold prices. Now, with the advent of blockchain technology, tokenised gold has entered the scene, touted as a revolutionary bridge between the physical and digital realms. Yet, beneath this innovative veneer lies the potential for tokenised gold to serve as yet another mechanism in the longstanding tradition of gold price suppression.
Historical Mechanisms of Gold Price Suppression
Before delving into the nuances of tokenised gold, it’s imperative to understand the existing tools that have been employed to manipulate gold prices. These instruments have created a complex web of financial products that, while offering investors various avenues to gain exposure to gold, have also facilitated the suppression of its price.
- Futures Contracts: Platforms like the COMEX allow traders to buy and sell gold futures—agreements to purchase or sell gold at a predetermined price at a future date. While they provide a means for hedging and speculation, these contracts often result in price movements that are detached from the actual physical supply and demand of gold. The sheer volume of paper gold traded in these markets can overshadow the physical market, leading to price distortions.
- Unallocated Gold Accounts: Many banks offer unallocated gold accounts where clients are essentially creditors rather than outright owners of specific gold quantities. In such arrangements, the bank may not hold sufficient physical gold to cover all accounts, relying instead on fractional reserves. This practice introduces counterparty risks and allows for the expansion of paper gold supply, which can suppress prices.
- Gold Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs): ETFs like GLD enable investors to gain exposure to gold prices without holding the physical metal. However, questions have been raised about the transparency of these funds regarding their actual physical gold holdings. The potential for these ETFs to lease out their gold or engage in other activities can impact the supply dynamics and, consequently, the price of gold.
These examples represent just a fraction of the myriad ways in which gold prices can be and have been suppressed through financial engineering. The introduction of tokenised gold adds a new layer to this intricate landscape.
Tokenised Gold: A New Player in an Old Game
Tokenised gold involves representing physical gold assets as digital tokens on a blockchain. Each token typically corresponds to a specific amount of physical gold stored in a secure vault. This concept promises to combine the intrinsic value of gold with the flexibility and accessibility of digital assets. However, despite its innovative facade, tokenised gold currently represents a minuscule fraction of the overall gold market.
As of March 2025, the market capitalization of tokenised gold reached a record $1.4 billion. Leading the market are Tether’s XAUT and Paxos’ PAXG, with market capitalizations of $749 million and $653 million, respectively. In contrast, the total market capitalization of all above-ground gold is estimated to be around $20.9 trillion. This means tokenised gold constitutes merely 0.0067% of the total gold market—a tiny sliver in the grand scheme.
While this market segment is currently small, its growth trajectory suggests increasing interest. Trading volumes for tokenised gold surpassed $1.6 billion in March 2025, the highest level in more than a year. This burgeoning interest raises critical questions about the potential implications of tokenised gold on the broader gold market, particularly concerning price dynamics and suppression mechanisms.
The Practical Challenges of Physical Redemption
One of the touted benefits of tokenised gold is the potential for physical redemption. In theory, token holders can exchange their digital assets for actual gold bars or coins. However, redeeming small quantities of physical gold presents significant challenges that often render the process impractical:
- High Costs: The expenses associated with management, shipping, and insurance can be prohibitive for small-scale redemptions, often outweighing the value of the gold itself.
- Verification Difficulties: Authenticating the purity and weight of physical gold requires specialized equipment and expertise, making it impractical for the average investor.
- Storage and Security Concerns: Owning physical gold necessitates secure storage solutions, which can be costly and inconvenient, deterring individuals from opting for physical possession.
Consequently, while tokenised gold offers a digital representation of the precious metal, the logistical hurdles associated with physical redemption mean that most investors may never take possession of actual gold. This detachment from the physical asset mirrors the dynamics of other gold derivatives, where the metal itself remains untouched, and the potential for price suppression persists.
Government Incentives to Suppress Gold Prices
Governments and central banks have historically exhibited a vested interest in controlling gold prices. A rising gold price can signal a lack of confidence in fiat currencies, potentially undermining their stability. By suppressing gold prices, authorities aim to maintain the illusion of economic stability and control over inflation. For instance, during the 1960s, the London Gold Pool—a consortium of central banks—actively intervened in the gold market to maintain a fixed price and deter gold from competing with the U.S. dollar.
In contemporary times, central banks may engage in practices such as selling gold reserves or using derivatives to influence gold prices. These actions are often motivated by the desire to protect the perceived value of fiat currencies and to prevent gold from serving as a barometer of economic instability. The introduction of tokenised gold could provide yet another avenue for such interventions, allowing for more sophisticated and less transparent methods of price control.
Conclusion: Navigating the Complexities of Tokenised Gold
While tokenised gold presents an innovative fusion of traditional assets and modern technology, it is essential to approach this development with a critical eye. The historical context of gold price suppression, combined with the practical challenges of physical redemption and the potential for governmental manipulation, suggests that tokenised gold may not be the panacea it appears to be.
Investors should be vigilant and demand transparency, robust auditing, and clear redemption mechanisms when engaging with tokenised gold.
Hopefully this entire post is wrong!
Explore More:
Leave a Reply